Inside JSTOR’s semi-annual process for evaluating publisher submissions and adding approximately 300 new scholarly monographs to a growing open access program

Selecting books for Path to Open is not simply a matter of ranking submissions by popularity. JSTOR’s annual process asks a wider question: How can a shared collection respond to readers’ interests while making room for scholarship that is newer, less visible, or not yet well represented?

Participating presses submit monographs for consideration, and JSTOR’s editorial team reviews those submissions in phases as it works to build a collection that balances scholarly value, discipline focus, anticipated demand, potential impact, and bibliodiversity. The selections shape not only what participating libraries can use before the open access transition, but also which scholarship will become more widely available over time. Libraries also provide their usage data of licensed and open content to identify the top disciplines, which helps guide the curation process. We then consult with publishers who are aligned and agree in supporting these disciplines. This evidence-driven curatorial process will continue to be a guiding principle for our future curation process. 

Black-and-white photograph of a woman reaching for a book on a library shelf
Library Accessioning. Undated. Images from the History of Medicine, U.S. National Library of Medicine.

The process reflects broader community priorities shaped with input from Path to Open’s Community Advisory Committee. Convened by the American Council of Learned Societies (ACLS), the committee brings together scholars, librarians, and publishers to advise on the program’s goals and development, helping keep equity, sustainability, and transparency at the center of the model. JSTOR’s editorial team considers those priorities alongside the needs of readers and the collection. 

Bibliodiversity is more than a count of disciplines

A discipline count can tell us something about a collection, but not enough to make the collection meaningful. Bibliodiversity also includes the range of publishers, perspectives, methods, topics, and scholarly communities represented in the books.

This matters because scholarly publishing helps determine which questions are visible and which forms of knowledge are available for teaching and research. Open access can broaden a book’s audience, but broader access alone does not guarantee that a collection reflects the range of scholarship being produced in the world today.

That shared perspective matters. Publishers know their lists and editorial programs; librarians see how collections serve teaching and research; authors and scholars understand the questions shaping their fields. No single viewpoint can describe the whole ecosystem.

From publisher submissions to a shared, cohesive cohort

The process begins with submissions from more than 50 participating presses during two rounds: fall and spring. JSTOR provides each publisher with guidance to submit up to15 books for consideration. This range gives presses with different publishing scales and subject strengths a meaningful opportunity to participate, since publishers vary in scale. Each Path to Open cohort year has an annual cap of 300 selected titles. 

Ahead of the submission period, selection methodology materials are provided to publishers to help them understand what the reviewers are and aren’t looking for. Each publisher provides information about its submissions, such as each book’s contributors, subject, discipline, description, scholarly focus, and publication timeline, as well as any available reviewer feedback or marketing information. 

JSTOR always receives very strong submissions in every cycle, which can make the selection process difficult. Because the annual cohort is capped at 300 titles, not every strong submission can be selected. A book may not be selected because another title is a closer fit for the collection’s balance, several similar books have been submitted, or because the collection already includes a comparable contribution. Those decisions are about overall collection fit and discipline focus.

The Path to Open selection process is about how a title fits the program’s priorities, including scholarly value, disciplinary focus, anticipated demand, potential impact, and bibliodiversity. 

Demand is one signal, not the whole decision

Beyond our program’s general disciplinary focus, usage and search data help JSTOR understand what readers are researching and where open access may have the potential to expand reach. Our selection methodology considers ebook usage across licensed books, open access books, and books that moved from licensed access to open access. It also considers JSTOR search activity: the topics readers look for and the use associated with those searches.

This evidence helps bring in the voices of the library and users into the selection process to help identify areas of demonstrated interest, ensure titles are published that address the highest demand, and support a more consistent review. 

A multi-stage review process builds a balanced list

Selection moves from individual submissions to a proposed collection in several stages. First, JSTOR’s editorial team uses the evidence as a guideline to understand which books best connect to disciplines and topics with strong usage or active research interest. Reviewers look beyond a publisher’s initial classification when a book’s subject can serve more than one scholarly community.

Next, the team looks across the emerging list. Which disciplines are becoming concentrated? Are a range of publishers represented? Do books on similar topics make distinct contributions? Where can the collection include a wider range of perspectives, methods, regions, and scholarly communities?

Reviewers also consider if a new edition or a first-time translation add substantive content or reach readers who might not otherwise encounter the work. These questions help the program make room for specialized scholarship while considering how books can be discovered and used across a broader research community.

What the data can, and can’t, tell us

JSTOR can measure changes in usage, institutional reach, geographic reach, and engagement by discipline.However, a book’s influence on teaching, policy, public discussion, or research may not appear in simple usage data.

The evidence needs to be described carefully: open access can expand use and reach across a diverse set of scholarly books; the first 100 titles to become open access represent 29 disciplines, while titles added from 2023 to 2025 represent 48 disciplines, with more titles continuing to enter the program; thoughtful selection can connect bibliodiversity with discoverability. These measurements don’t provide a complete account of bibliodiversity or impact, of course.

Curation with a conscience

As Path to Open grows, the selection approach will continue to evolve. JSTOR will keep examining usage and search evidence, listening to presses and libraries, and asking which communities or forms of scholarship may still be missing from an open access perspective. The goal is not an artificial quota for every discipline or a prediction of which books will become most popular, it is to make deliberate choices about breadth while remaining accountable to readers, authors, publishers, and libraries.

Demand helps us understand where readers are looking, potential impact helps us imagine who else might be reached, and bibliodiversity reminds us not to confuse existing visibility with the full range of scholarship worth supporting. This is why a strong Path to Open collection needs all three elements to be successful.

The question is not only, “Is this a good book?” It is also, “What does this book add to the collection we are building?” For more on how Path to Open advances these goals, explore the Insight Brief.

Written by:

author headshot

Cristina Mezuk

Cristina Mezuk is the Manager of Content Operations, Curation & Management. Cristina works closely with publishers in the Path to Open pilot. She manages the publisher-specific workflows, title selection processes, and documentation for books in the pilot to ensure things run efficiently.